HR Newswire sign up
Follow us on twitter
Search:

SOCIAL HR
Jun 25, 2012

If CEOs value talent (and they do) why does HR struggle for resources?

Human resources professionals need to adopt entrepreneurial stance
    

By Harpaul Sambhi

At the tender age of two, I already knew I would be a people person.

I became entrepreneurial by renaming Fruit Loops “Harpaul Loops,” often selling small bags of cereal to my neighbours to pay for candy. Infringement warnings from Kellogg’s aside, I had a feeling it wasn’t the last time I would use my passion and never-give-up attitude to sell something of value.

I used that entrepreneurial spirit to start my first business — helping companies recruit some of the top graduates in universities across Canada. Over the years, I’ve had the opportunity to meet hundreds of CEOs across Canada and now, with my technology business Careerify, many more across the world.

I continually hear that, for a majority of CEOs, the greatest challenge is talent. Whether it’s recruiting great employees, engaging them to foster innovation or a focus on retention, talent is almost always top of mind. That’s why recruitment is a multibillion dollar industry.

I recently met with a group of HR technology executives. They represented diverse organizations, ranging from startups to mature software businesses.

They spoke about the consistent horrors of selling into HR, continuously facing an uphill battle with a financially strapped business unit that struggles to be heard at the executive table. Maybe the vendor’s solution wasn’t appealing. Perhaps it did a poor job identifying current needs. Or maybe they just came off as arrogant.

But what disturbs me is this large disconnect between vendors and CEO challenges, and hearing some HR departments say they don’t “have budget.”

In his bestselling book Winning, former GE CEO Jack Welch said: “Without doubt, the head of HR should be the second most important person in any organization.”

Yet, according to an Achievers report, only seven per cent report directly to the CEO. Are CEOs delusional when, on one hand, they say talent is a top challenge and, on the other, don’t allow the company to make investments on processes and products to address this issue?

Are HR vendors so behind the time they don’t know how to engage their buyers? Is HR truly dead, as some have speculated in the past?  Or are those that run HR not entrepreneurial enough to build a business case to innovate their company?

The world needs more entrepreneurs or, at the very least, “intrepreneurs.” HR needs to create a stronger voice that proves to the C-suite it isn’t a “cost center.” HR should report into the CEO, and not the CFO.

We need to push our technology vendors, forcing them to build innovative processes that are intuitive for the true end-user, which is the employee or candidate, and not for HR. Vendors need to support us with metrics that predict the ideal candidate, trends on performance and identify star employees. We need to stop being conservative and set aside a small amount of budget for risk. Finally, we need to stop looking at our department, and start thinking about the overall business.

Our talent generates revenue for the business. Figure out what each employee is worth in revenue, and you will quickly get the CEO’s attention for each day those positions aren’t filled or when performance is subpar. This embodies the quintessential entrepreneur: Understanding the root cause, looking for ways to optimize and not giving up until you get what you want.

What is it that you want? My guess would be that it’s not money, but a voice.

Harpaul Sambhi is the CEO of Careerify, a company that develops social recruiting tools focused on employee referral programs with offices in Toronto and San Francisco. He is the author of Social HR, published by Carswell, which sheds insights in how social media is impacting human resources. He can be reached at hsambhi@careerify.net, (416) 840-6216 or visit www.careerify.net for more information.

    
COMMENT ON THIS BLOG POST
Headline for your comment (Optional)
Name (Required)    
Email Address (Required, will not be published)
Comment (Required)
All comments are moderated and usually appear within 24 hours of posting. Email address will not be published.
COMMENTS
HR should adopt consultant mentality
Monday, July 23, 2012 9:30:00 PM by Daneal Charney
Of course HR needs solid business knowledge. Internal HR people should adopt a consultant mentality. Learning the business and what the business measures quickly. You can only get senior leaders to shift their thinking if you meet them where they are, NOT where you are. HR is about how you can help mitigate risk or seize new business opportunities.
HR does need business knowledge
Wednesday, June 27, 2012 10:31:00 AM by Mark
Harpaul this is certainly a great conversation and thank you for writing this blog. I think that job experience is important in HR, but I do agree that in order to grow in the organization HR professionals, and this is specifically for senior HR people, they need to understand numbers and how to align strategy to business goals, developing formulas and equations to define return on investment, communicating effectively with senior management through clear and effective business cases and creating strategic plans to make the business more efficient and prosperous. If HR professionals want to be "business partners" then it would help to gain some education in business through an MBA or even a general business certificate, which will help make that HR professional more well rounded. I don't think they need to all go out and get business degrees per say - but some education wouldn't hurt.
To answer the last point, if HR fails to be able to prove its worth through numbers etc. then HR in most organization cannot be an equal partner to the CEO or provide the necessary input to impact the organization positively.
HR does need business knowledge
Wednesday, June 27, 2012 10:03:00 AM by Harpaul Sambhi
Love the comments. This is exactly the conversations we need to have. Mark - do you believe a HR professional with number of years of experience currently working at a job does not get exposed with experience to gain business knowledge? How do they formulate a business case, as per Sam's comment? If they continue to fail with building a credible business case, where does HR go wrong?
HR does need business knowledge
Wednesday, June 27, 2012 9:24:00 AM by Mark
I agree with Sam - leaders are not born they are taught. The same goes for business skills - even though you do not necessarily have to have a business degree, you still need to gain business knowledge through training, experience and education.
HR needs a transformation from the touchy-feely to the business-oriented mindset
Wednesday, June 27, 2012 9:20:00 AM by Sam Stout
Yes engineers may find success in technology companies, but even they require sound business knowledge in order to cater to the business world. By business background what is meant is having a sound understanding of the fundamentals of business - which you would learn studying business or even achieving an MBA. Whether you are an engineer, computer scientist or even a mathematician - you NEED an understanding of business to serve the needs of business. Engineers are not taught in school the intricacies of formulating a business case for example - and this is required in the business world.
HR needs a transformation from the touchy-feely to the business-oriented mindset
Wednesday, June 27, 2012 8:52:00 AM by Harpaul Sambhi
I appreciate your comments Sam. I question the notion of having a business background means they understand business. Careerify, Microsoft, and HP are some of the companies that would have been failed long ago since they are led by engineers, but selling to businesses. I think what is lacking is the understanding the overall picture. We are not recruiting employees for the sake of headcount or building different comp plans to better differentiate ourselves from our competitors.
HR needs a transformation from the touchy-feely to the business-oriented mindset
Tuesday, June 26, 2012 3:36:00 PM by Sam Stout
Most HR professionals don't have a business background and so are not taken seriously by the CEO for the simple fact that they don't understand business. The majority of HR professionals couldn't calculate the return on investment on most of their HR programs, which is why they also don't know the types of software that can help them figure this out! Bottom line is HR needs a transformation from the "touchy-feely" to the more business-orientated mindset. Now, in all fairness, calculating ROI is a very difficult and often daunting task, however there are metrics out there that can help come close to measuring HR effectiveness.