Memo to HR: ‘You’re a bunch of corporate suck-ups who say a lot and do very little’
Anti-human resources venom in reader comments on newspaper website raises question: Why is HR such a popular punching bag?
Jan 24, 2011
By Todd Humber (firstname.lastname@example.org)
Why is HR such a popular punching bag?
In 2005, Fast Company magazine ran a scathing piece entitled “Why we hate HR” that stirred up quite a bit of controversy in the profession.
Fast forward six years, and HR still isn’t feeling much love from the general public. Canadian HR Reporter teamed up with the Human Resources Professionals Association (HRPA) to conduct a Pulse Survey on problem managers.
The Toronto Star picked up on the story, and ran a version of it on their website. But what was telling was the comments from readers.
The majority of the comments were sharing stories about bosses from hell, or just griping in general, but more than a few comments took a run at human resources.
Here’s a sampling:
•“Ha, what a joke! Not only are bosses cutthroat and abusive nowadays, but worse are the HR reps! From government to private, the HR department represents the coldest, inhuman part of an organization.”
•“I find some of the HR people are from hell. My section of the company is unionized. (HR) hates it and it shows.”
•“I’m both surprised and shocked that HR departments are reporting this. It is a very difficult to bring up a bad manager with some HR departments, at least where I work.”
•One reader suggested that everyone “disliking” the anti-HR comments on the story were HR professionals. “Disagree all you want whilst you do your 9-4 job while others that actually do something and actually work will continue to ensure you have a job… dead weight!!”
•“But what about HR from hell? These people who are way overpaid and way underworked are the true enemies. Think they are there for you the employee? Think again! Make a complaint against your employer through them and you’ll be the next to go. HR’s a bunch of corporate suck ups who say a lot and do very little.”
•“You know what takes up too much time? Human resources. When did HR managers start making more than the people who actually drive the business? Uh, thanks. We need a total makeover of our corporate identity. Useless HR complaints and forms and feelings are what drives real managers crazy. Ha!”
•“I haven’t met an HR employee/manager/executive that wasn’t a little (to a lot) odd. I would take their observations and recommendations with a grain of salt. As the motto goes — those that can do and those that can’t go into HR!”
•“And when did the HR department start to care? This whole thing has been happening right under their noses and they did squat. HR is not there for you, HR is there to do what the boss tells them to do.”
Venomous comments on media websites should, of course, be taken with a grain of salt. But do you think HR professionals get the respect they deserve? And if not, why?
Todd Humber is the managing editor of Canadian HR Reporter, the national journal of human resource management. For more information, visit www.hrreporter.com.
Todd Humber is the publisher and editor-in-chief of Canadian HR Reporter, the national journal of human resource management. Follow him on Twitter @ToddHumber