Publisher's Desk|Canadian HR Law|HR Policies & Practices|Employment Law|The C-Suite|HR Guest Blog

Potential for backlash relating to temporary foreign workers

Some people may be misplacing their anger

By Brian Kreissl

Am I the only person who is a little worried about the potential backlash surrounding the furor over the Temporary Foreign Workers Program in recent weeks?

While I completely understand the government’s reaction to the controversy by “naming and shaming” organizations alleged to have misused the program and shutting down the program for restaurants and fast food outlets (at least for the time being) I fear many members of the general public may be getting the wrong idea.

In some respects, I believe this could be driving anti-immigrant sentiment among some people. I personally think we need to do a better job of clarifying the issue and protecting people from mistreatment related to fears about foreigners coming into the country and taking our jobs.

Differences between temporary foreign workers, immigrants

Let’s face it, many people don’t really understand the difference between temporary foreign workers and immigrants who are permanent residents (and even naturalized Canadian Citizens in some cases). It’s unfortunate, but some people just have a xenophobic attitude and simply see the issue as being one of “Canadians” versus “foreigners.”

Those people often don’t stop to consider the fact that some of the people they assume are foreigners are actually Canadian Citizens with every right to live and work in this country. I’ve personally met more than a few people who have a very narrow — and downright racist — definition of who exactly is considered to be “Canadian.”

Because of that, I can foresee the very real possibility of some bigot getting angry and taking his spite out on an immigrant when she’s serving him his morning coffee at the local drive-through. But that person serving him coffee may very well be a permanent resident who was an engineer or physician back home and is just taking a job in a coffee house to make ends meet.

In all likelihood, such a person was probably told her qualifications are highly in demand in Canada. She likely spent several years on a waiting list and came to Canada at great personal expense and risk to her career, often having to start over from scratch.

Paradoxically, I believe new immigrants — along with young people — are the people who suffer the most under the Temporary Foreign Workers Program. But why is it that recent immigrants have such a hard time gaining Canadian experience when other people — who haven’t made a permanent commitment to this country – seem to be able to jump the queue?

Canada needs immigrants, especially since our low birth rate means there aren’t enough new entrants into the labour force domestically. The only way to help ensure we continue to grow, remain productive, slow down the aging population and obtain some of the skills we need is through immigration.

But even if someone is a temporary foreign worker, they still deserve to be treated with dignity and respect and in accordance with the principles of fundamental human rights. I would never advocate discrimination or failure to honour existing agreements with such individuals.

In most cases, those people are stuck in low wage jobs – often the type of work many Canadians turn their noses up at. But because they are here on temporary work visas, they cannot simply quit and go and work somewhere else, and in many cases they’re separated from their families for years at a time.

It isn’t their fault some Canadian employers got greedy and started to look abroad to fill their low-skill, low-wage jobs, nor is it their fault many Canadian workers are perceived to be lazy and entitled. And in many cases, temporary foreign workers do help deal with skills shortages or are willing to take the types of jobs few Canadians are willing to do.

Making a permanent commitment to Canada

But as several commentators have asked, shouldn’t we be giving people who are willing to make a permanent commitment to this country priority over people who are just here on a temporary work permit?

While I think we should be questioning just who and how many people we let into this country, for what purpose and for how long, we have an obligation to treat the people fairly who are already here – whether they be foreign workers, immigrants or Canadian Citizens.

Perhaps we shouldn’t be letting in quite so many temporary foreign workers so that immigrants and young people get a better chance to get a proper foothold in the labour force?

© Copyright Canadian HR Reporter, Thomson Reuters Canada Limited. All rights reserved.

Brian Kreissl

Brian Kreissl is the product development manager for Thomson Reuters Legal Canada's human resources, OH&S, payroll and records retention products and solutions.
(Required, will not be published)
All comments are moderated and usually appear within 24 hours of posting. Email address will not be published.
  • RE: Really?
    Tuesday, April 29, 2014 10:24:00 PM by Brian Kreissl
    I seriously doubt anyone is going to read my blog post and decide to be rude to people in fast food outlets because of it. If anything, I was hoping it would make at least some people think twice about such behaviour (although I really don't think many people who follow this blog would be guilty of that sort of thing).

    I am glad you have such a positive outlook and believe we have moved beyond racism and other types of prejudice. While I personally believe the vast majority of people are decent and wouldn't dream of treating a fellow human being badly based on where they are from, I am sad to say such things do still happen at times. I have personally met people who were downright hostile to people just because they spoke with a different accent (and pretended not to understand them). I have also argued with people who seemed to believe that only people who look a certain way count as "real" Canadians, even when talking about people who were born here.

    My basic message was that all of this talk about the Temporary Foreign Workers Program could be feeding into some people's xenophobia and anti-immigrant sentiment. I also wanted to make it clear that temporary foreign workers aren't personally to blame for the misuse of this program (which appears to be a real problem, especially when Canadians are fired from their jobs so they can be replaced with foreign workers).