Written agreements are critical when a secondment ends early, legal expert says
Lending an employee to another organization for a project is not uncommon — but a recent decision involving the federal Major Projects Office (MPO) is raising questions about the risks seconded employees can bring.
In document provided by the House of Commons environment committee, the MPO — a federal special operating agency established to speed up the process for projects considered in the national interest — will be receiving 17 employees lent by private sector organizations, according to CBC News.
The seconded employees are coming from various companies across different sectors — including banking, railways and energy — such as Scotiabank, CN Rail and TC Energy. Pembina Pipeline Corporation, which currently holds a 10-per-cent stake in the West Coast oil pipeline project, has also lent one worker to the MPO.
In a recent parliamentary committee hearing, MPs raised concerns about the involvement of private sector employees — specifically on how those employees could be subject to government conflict-of-interest rules.
Nadia Aruza, employment lawyer at Simes Law in Toronto, says while conflict of interest can be a real issue, the most pressing concern that employers face in these circumstances is what happens when the project ends.
“If the secondment ends before it was meant to, it’s just important to delineate who was responsible,” she says.
What is a secondment?
A secondment does not always mean an organization is lending an employee to a completely different organization — sometimes it can be an internal move within the same company, Aruza says.
“A company could say, 'We’re going to second you to another location or another department,'" she says.
However, the circumstance that tends to come up most often is employees being lent between the private and federal sectors for specific projects, she says. According to a briefing document obtained by CBC News, two dozen MPO employees have also been seconded from federal, provincial and territorial governments.
The key point, Aruza says, is that they are lent for a project: .
“This assignment tends to be project-based,” she says.
The importance of a strong secondment agreement
A main aspect Aruza says employers need to ensure is having a strong secondment agreement that clarifies who is the actual employer.
In the case of the MPO, CBC News reports that the employees’ home companies will be covering 100 per cent of their salaries and benefits. That matters, Aruza says, because if the secondment ends early, it is important to know who is responsible for severance packages.
“From the employee’s perspective, maybe they’re getting their compensation entirely from their original employer, but there might be some reimbursement obligations that the two companies or the two institutions have worked out,” Aruza says.
Both the employers and the employee would want to have discussed severance package arrangements before the secondment begins, she says.
According to the government of Canada’s website on assignments and secondments, the written agreement must also clarify whether the employee will return to their "substantive position" after the secondment ends and whether their career development and progress will be protected by the home organization. It should also address the impact on performance pay, duties, tasks, approval of leave, and any host organization responsibilities on employee training, accommodation and duty to accommodate.
The reason an agreement ending early can be a problem, is if the seconded employee’s position has been backfilled at the home organization, Aruza says.
“Let’s say this employment ends earlier than everyone anticipated, and the employer is not willing to terminate the replacement, and there’s nothing comparable — that can lead to the end of the employment relationship.”
She recommends that the agreement include language clarifying whether the employee gets to come back if their position is available — or whether they will be placed in a comparable position.
Conflict of interest and confidentiality
When it comes to the conflict-of-interest aspect, Aruza says there must be clarity around whether an employee owes duties of loyalty and good faith to the host organization.
For example, in circumstances like the MPO, there could be an issue of corporate opportunity — where an employee working for a federal public agency could become aware of information that benefits their home employer, she says.
“Someone, by virtue of this arrangement, shouldn’t necessarily be exposed to information that the rest of us don’t have and be able to profit from it themselves or their company.”
That is why there should be a confidentiality clause in the agreement, according to Aruza.
“Having confidentiality clauses and clear delineations of what is and isn’t permitted when it comes to confidential information — the skills that you have developed through your work belong to you, but you can’t use confidential information to perform the secondment, and vice versa.”