KDM Constructors LP v The International Union of Operating Engineers Local 870

Firms involved

Seiferling Law, Gerrand Rath Johnson LLP, Ministry of Justice Saskatchewan - Legal Services Division, Unrepresented, Neuman Thompson
KDM Constructors LP
Law Firm
Seiferling Law
Lawyer(s)

Steven J.R. Seiferling

The International Union of Operating Engineers Local 870
Law Firm
Gerrand Rath Johnson LLP
Lawyer(s)

Rick A. Engel, K.C.

Attorney General of Saskatchewan
Law Firm
Ministry of Justice Saskatchewan - Legal Services Division
Lawyer(s)

Katherine Roy

Saskatchewan Labour Relations Board
Law Firm
Unrepresented
Saskatchewan Building Trades Council
Law Firm
Gerrand Rath Johnson LLP
Lawyer(s)

Gregory Fingas

Turner Ridley Purcell

Boilermaker Contractors’ Association
Law Firm
Unrepresented
CLR Construction Labour Relations Association of Saskatchewan Inc.
Law Firm
Neuman Thompson
Lawyer(s)

Hugh J.D. McPhail, K.C.

Background:
The International Union of Operating Engineers, Local 870, applied to the Saskatchewan Labour Relations Board for certification as the bargaining agent for operating engineers employed by KDM Constructors LP. These employees were working at the construction site of the BHP Jansen potash mine. KDM opposed the certification, claiming the employees’ work constituted “maintenance work,” not “construction activity,” under the Saskatchewan Employment Act (SEA). KDM also challenged the constitutionality of the SEA’s requirement to participate in collective bargaining through a representative employer organization (REO).

Key Legal Issues:

  1. Applicability of the Saskatchewan Employment Act (SEA):
    The Court upheld the Board’s decision that the work performed—transporting water, removing sewage, and mixing concrete—was integral to the mine’s construction and not maintenance activity.

  2. Constitutional Challenge Under the Charter:
    KDM argued that the SEA’s requirement to join an REO violated its freedom of association under Section 2(d) of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The Court ruled that corporate entities like KDM are not entitled to this protection, which is aimed at balancing power in employment relationships.

Costs and Awards:
Costs were awarded to the International Union of Operating Engineers, Local 870, in the usual manner. Specific monetary amounts were not detailed.

Court of Appeal for Saskatchewan
CACV4073
Labour & Employment Law
Respondent