Peer recognition stands out most — but getting it wrong can backfire, expert says

Coworker recognition is nearly twice as memorable as senior leader recognition, report finds

Peer recognition stands out most — but getting it wrong can backfire, expert says

For some employees, the most memorable recognition is not coming from their manager or boss — it’s coming from their colleagues. 

Thirty-three per cent of employees say a message from a coworker stands out more, compared to 23 per cent from their manager and 17 per cent from senior leaders, according to the Recognition That Lands report published by Kudos in 2026.  

A recognition message is nearly twice as likely to stand out when it comes from a coworker rather than a senior leader. 

However, Pei Wang, assistant professor at the University of Guelph in Ontario, says while peer recognition programs can be great to implement, they must be done with an understanding of the workplace culture in mind — or things can backfire. 

“Before you go out there and purchase that software [or] peer recognition program, you should first consider ‘What’s the true reason that there is not enough helping behaviour among workers?’ ‘Are we promoting too much competition among workers?’” he says. 

The research was conducted by Leger and included 805 employees and 43 organizational leaders across 18 industries 

Why peer recognition works 

There are two layers in human psychology that explain why recognition from a colleague can be more impactful than recognition from a manager, Wang says. 

As human beings, people are constantly seeking evidence and support that they are a good person, he says. “Peer recognition serves as a strong example to help us reassure that we’re doing good things, we’re being a good person,” he says. “It makes us feel good about ourselves.” 

It also plays into the basic human interaction of reciprocity — creating a relationship where that reciprocity will continue to happen, Wang says. 

The top three recognition moments that stood out to respondents, according to the report, included: 

  • helping a teammate or team succeed 
  • supporting one another through difficult times 
  • recognizing an everyday contribution that might otherwise go unnoticed.

Why it can become a problem 

Problems with these programs can arise when managers implement or purchase the platforms without first understanding the workplace, Wang says. 

His own research, published in the Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences, found that these systems can have unintended consequences. 

Often, there is a misconception that peer recognition programs can help behaviours between employees, he says. Instead, these systems can do the opposite — creating competition and a culture of reluctance to help one another. 

“If you encourage competition among workers, they will become more reluctant to help each other. Because if I help you, then maybe you will win the competition,” he says. 

In some cases, the issue is not recognition at all — but workers lacking the capability to help each other, which Wang says any recognition program cannot solve. 

The software and rewards issue 

Recognition platforms tend to work on a similar core function — where someone can post about an employee’s kindness and rewards are given when the recognition happens, Wang says. 

However, the question of who gets to review those posts can defeat the purpose of trying to cultivate a culture of kindness, he says. 

“The more people see the post, the more the risk of social comparison is also going to become higher,” Wang says. “Because everyone will have some different opinions on what deserves the recognition and what may be passed on recognition.” 

Wang’s research suggests this can significantly impact a worker’s perception of fairness. 

Finding the sweet spot of recognition 

To make peer recognition programs work, with or without the software systems, they must be public and have a common agreement on when a recognition should happen, Wang says. He says that sweet spots tend to focus on or highlight the behaviour of a worker who stands out from others. 

“There must be some prior comparison. Before you make that recognition, you’re going to think twice on whether this level of help can make this worker stand out from other workers,” Wang says. 

The common ground not only helps when life gets busy and the recognition is deprioritized, but also if others forget to recognize each other. 

“These guidelines for peer recognition will really help prevent the peer recognition system from backfiring,” he says. 

Latest stories