Eight boards in Canada hold $4.5 billion above target, and employers want new rebate rules: survey
Employers in seven provinces and Yukon could recover thousands of dollars each – about $2,600 on average for a business with five workers – if governments force workers’ compensation boards to return surplus premiums, according to research from the Canadian Federation of Independent Business (CFIB) released Nov. 16, 2026.
In its annual funding snapshot, CFIB reports that 84% of small business owners, surveyed in June 2026, support legislation requiring workers’ compensation boards (WCBs) to return surplus funds once a board exceeds its funding target.
CFIB counts eight overfunded boards, from British Columbia to Newfoundland and Labrador, holding a combined $4.5 billion above their targets as of Dec. 31, 2025, up from seven boards a year earlier.
Ontario the only province with a surplus rebate law
Ontario’s Workplace Safety and Insurance Board (WSIB), the model CFIB favours, must distribute surpluses once its funding ratio reaches 125% and may do so from 115%. The WSIB returned $4 billion in two rounds in 2025, including the second $2-billion surplus distribution to eligible Ontario businesses, while staying inside its target range, CFIB says.
“With rising costs and economic uncertainty, now is not the time for boards to hold onto money that belongs to the employers who paid it,” said Kalith Nanayakkara, CFIB’s senior policy analyst for British Columbia and a co-author of the snapshot.
Rebates or rate cuts?
British Columbia, above target for a decade according to CFIB, takes a different route. For 2027, WorkSafeBC plans to return about $960 million in surplus, mostly through base rates priced below system costs. CFIB argues that approach can mask rising expenses, noting 48% of B.C. employers face base rate hikes in 2027.
WCB Nova Scotia chose a rate cut instead, lowering its average assessment rate by 15% to $2.25 per $100 of payroll in 2027. It arrives alongside full cost-of-living indexing of injured workers’ benefits.
What a mandatory rebate would mean for HR and payroll
For HR and payroll teams, legislation would bring a predictable timeline. CFIB’s estimates range from about $670 for a five-employee firm in Nova Scotia to roughly $8,600 in Yukon, though actual amounts would vary with payroll and claims history.
“A rebate of a few thousand dollars can make a real difference for a small business. Owners could put that money toward workplace safety, wages or simply keeping their doors open,” said Jonathan Galgay, CFIB’s director for Newfoundland and Labrador and the snapshot’s other co-author.
Psychological injury claims could test the surplus
Those surpluses may not last. Accepted psychological-injury-only claims in B.C. rose 51% between 2021 and 2025, according to WorkSafeBC data cited by CFIB.
B.C. employers also face proposed rules to assess and document psychosocial hazards, detailed in what BC’s proposed psychosocial hazard rules would require of employers. Chris Gardner, president and CEO of the Independent Contractors and Businesses Association (ICBA) in British Columbia, called the proposal “the most far-reaching expansion of WorkSafeBC’s regulatory authority in a generation” in September 2026.
Prevention may offer common ground. WorkSafeNB reported traumatic psychological injury claims fell 26% in 2025, which it credits to prevention and mental health supports – the kind of investment that sets apart the best companies to work for in Canada. CFIB is urging governments to legislate surplus returns with set thresholds and timelines.