At HRFest Canada, Zurich Canada AVP and Wells Fargo director say content-focused L&D is most at risk
AI has changed the course of work for many functions, but for the L&D department, it is creating a question of whether it is really needed or worth investing in anymore.
At HRFest Canada, Lee Baudreau, AVP of enterprise learning and development at Zurich Canada, and Nick May, senior director of talent operations and technology at Wells Fargo, say AI might be killing the traditional training department model — but not L&D itself.
The purpose of what L&D has always been — shaping the employee experience and what organizations need — remains, they say.
The concern is also something felt globally. Last year, 43 per cent of 600 L&D leaders from the United States, United Kingdom, New Zealand and Australia believed AI could entirely replace their roles, according to the State of Learning and Development report published by LearnUpon.
“It might force us to redefine a little bit about how we create value and how we produce that for the organizations,” Baudreau says.
The session, “AI Ate the Training Department: What L&D Becomes Next,” was held at Rebel in Toronto on Nov. 11 and moderated by Deandra Filicetti, founder of Driven By Co.
There has always been cuts
Before exploring AI’s effect on L&D, Baudreau points out that L&D has always struggled to prove its value.
“There are definitely some questions, but this was always a challenge with L&D even before AI,” he says. “L&D budgets have historically always been one of the first that gets cut in any kind of budgetary clawback, and not always for unexplainable reasons.”
L&D has also always been hard to measure — and whether interventions and training are working is a point both speakers raise.
“The further out we go from a learning intervention, the harder it is to identify that in isolation from all the other variables," Baudreau says.
The way AI is changing L&D right now
In the age of AI, those L&D teams that continue to define themselves through the wrong value will end up being the most vulnerable, Baudreau says. That can happen if the focus is on providing training to the organization.
“If we primarily differentiate ourselves as a group who takes orders and produces content, and that’s how we determine our value — then do we still need one? Maybe not,” he says.
Baudreau points out that AI is already compressing the content production process — making it faster, cheaper, and increasingly scalable — so, it becomes a “dangerous game to play.”
With the amount of content being produced, he says the focus of L&D should be to produce less, with a focus on higher quality and the human touch.
“We already have learning libraries stuffed full of resources that people don’t access or don’t use. And we wonder, ‘Why don’t they go in and use these things?’” Baudreau says. “You still need that expertise in the professionals to be able to judge that quality or to create the standards that AI then uses to produce that quality”.
May says L&D teams can play a bigger role in the content curation process.
“Folks can help play a role in helping to understand how that information can and will be perceived across the organization,” he says. That can even mean making content AI-readable so that it can be repurposed and searchable.
“There’s always going to be trade-offs but understanding or being the voice in the room to say, ‘There’s too much going on right now, this isn’t going to land,’ is something that is incredibly important and a voice that I think L&D can continue to have at the table,” he says.
L&D’s role in building AI literacy
One of the roles L&D can play is helping build AI fluency across the workforce. However, both speakers say it should not be done alone.
For Baudreau, the focus should be on the capability building side — helping people learn how to use AI tools. But the responsibility needs to be shared — IT teams own the tools and the environment, risk and legal teams set the guardrails around what employees can and cannot do, and business leaders own the expectations for how their people use AI.
“I would strongly resist any urge to lean toward L&D being a sole owner for AI literacy and adoption,” he says.
This is especially important with constant change of AI tools, one of the biggest challenges organizations face, May says.
“The models that we’re using today are not the same models that we were using yesterday,” he says. “What was acceptable in your organization yesterday might not be the same as it is tomorrow.”
If anything, that creates a real opportunity for L&D to help the organization set realistic expectations around AI fluency, May says. “How we can chase that without making it just a continued goalpost that moves all the time.”
Where should L&D focus its efforts
With AI taking more of the content development role, Baudreau says L&D practitioners need to be thinking about where they spend their time — either “upstream” or “downstream.”
Upstream, he says, is focusing on diagnosing problems — looking at what performance problem or business problem exists before L&D tries to add training to fix it.
“That often is a reflex too — a performance issue equals training need, which is often not even true at all.” Sometimes problems can be “manager enablement,” Baudreau says, pointing to it as an example.
“You can train people until the end of time, but if the reason they’re not doing that behaviour has nothing to do with knowledge or awareness, you’re never going to solve the problem, and your training program is going to be deemed a failure,” he says.
This also plays into how to get the buy-in and budget for bringing L&D initiatives to the table, where there needs to be a demonstration of the business problem and how the solution will fix it, Baudreau says.
“Here is the business results we’re trying to get to, these are the capabilities that we need and the performance that we need to achieve those results, now here is an intervention or a plan or a program or something that’s going to drive measurable outcomes on that and get to the results.”
May points out that in his organization, the decision-making process focuses on the overall employee experience and whether it is “risk specific” or “something to help enable strong culture across the organization.”
Measuring what changes
On the downstream side, Baudreau says the focus should shift to whether performance or behaviour has changed.
“Metrics that you can look at, and especially if you have that evidence chain that you’ve already mapped out at the beginning, then each of those can become a dimension of measurement, and then you can identify certain key performance indicators that fit within that,” he says.
L&D does not need to own all problems but needs to look from a holistic lens of whether a learning intervention is part of the solution, May says.
“I think that L&D will always be important. The size and shape of that might change. It might become more centralized or decentralized. It might enable others to take L&D in other directions, but the actual work itself doesn’t go away. It just changes a bit.”