Decision provides guidance for employers during changing economic or operational circumstances
In Taylor v. Salytics Inc., 2026 ONCA 621, the Ontario Court of Appeal (ONCA) recently confirmed that a temporary layoff provision is not a termination provision and will not be rendered unenforceable simply because another termination provision in the employment agreement is invalid.
The decision provides helpful guidance for employers seeking to preserve the flexibility to temporarily lay off employees during changing economic or operational circumstances.
Temporary layoffs: legal framework
A temporary layoff occurs when an employer temporarily reduces or stops an employee’s work without ending the employment relationship. Under section 56(2) of the Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA), a layoff will generally qualify as temporary if it lasts no more than 13 weeks in any period of 20 consecutive weeks. A layoff may extend beyond 13 weeks, to less than 35 weeks in any period of 52 consecutive weeks, if one of the qualifying conditions in section 56(2)(b) is met (for example, the employer continuing benefit plan contributions).
Longer layoffs may qualify as temporary in limited cases, such as where a recall period is set out in a collective agreement or, for non-union employees, where the employer has a recall agreement with the employee and the Director has approved an extended layoff. If the layoff exceeds the applicable period, the ESA treats the employee’s employment as terminated, effective the first day of the layoff.
At common law, an employer’s right to temporarily lay off an employee may be an express or implied term of the employment relationship, including one established through a past practice of temporary layoffs by the employer or within the industry. Compliance with the ESA’s temporary layoff requirements does not, on its own, establish that right. Employers should therefore confirm their express or implied authority before implementing a temporary layoff: without that authority, even an ESA-compliant temporary layoff may amount to constructive dismissal, potentially entitling the employee to damages for reasonable notice.
In practical terms, an employer implementing a temporary layoff must satisfy both requirements: (i) the employer must have an express or implied contractual right to impose the layoff; and (ii) the layoff must comply with the ESA’s temporary layoff provisions.
Dispute in Taylor v. Salytics Inc.
In Taylor v. Salytics Inc., the employment agreement expressly permitted temporary layoffs in accordance with the ESA. The temporary layoff provision appeared under the agreement’s “Termination” heading, which provided:
Salytics may terminate your employment at any time for cause.
Salytics may terminate your employment without cause at any time by providing you with the minimum notice, or pay in lieu of such notice, and any severance pay required by the Employment Standards Act, 2000 and no more except in the event a layoff is required within the first six (6) months of your employment without cause, you will be entitled to continue receiving salary up to the end of this six month period.
In the event a temporary layoff is ever required, it may be implemented in accordance with the requirements of the Employment Standards Act, 2000.
Following financial difficulties, the employer placed the employee on a temporary layoff from April 1 to Sept. 30, 2024, during which his benefits continued. The employee sought a declaration that the layoff amounted to constructive dismissal and claimed damages equivalent to 12 months’ reasonable notice. The employee argued that the temporary layoff provision was unenforceable because the agreement’s “for cause” termination provision was invalid. The employer conceded that the “for cause” termination provision was unenforceable.
The employee argued that, under Waksdale v. Swegon North America Inc., 2020 ONCA 391, the invalid provision rendered the agreement’s other termination provisions unenforceable, including the temporary layoff provision.
The case therefore raised two key questions: (1) is a temporary layoff provision a termination provision and subject to the rule in Waksdale; and (2) if not, does placing the temporary layoff provision under the agreement’s “Termination” heading make it one?
The application decision
The application judge rejected both arguments, finding that the temporary layoff provision was not a termination provision and, therefore, was not affected by the invalid “for cause” provision.
The application judge explained that a temporary layoff may amount to a termination where the employment agreement does not give the employer the contractual right to temporarily lay off the employee. In contrast, where the employment agreement expressly permits temporary layoffs in accordance with the ESA, a compliant layoff does not amount to constructive dismissal and, therefore, does not constitute a termination.
The application judge emphasized substance over form, holding that the provision’s placement under the “Termination” heading did not change it into a termination provision.
Accordingly, the employee’s application was dismissed.
ONCA’s decision
The ONCA dismissed the employee’s appeal, agreeing that a temporary layoff provision is not a termination provision and does not become one simply because it appears in the termination section of an employment agreement.
The ONCA rejected the employee’s argument that a temporary layoff provision is necessarily a termination provision because a layoff is a “species” of termination. The ONCA emphasized that the ESA treats temporary layoffs and terminations as distinct concepts. Under section 56(1)(c), a layoff becomes a termination only when it extends beyond the period permitted for a temporary layoff under section 56(2). Similarly, section 56(4) provides that an employee who is laid off without a specified recall date is not considered terminated unless the layoff exceeds the permitted temporary layoff period. In other words, under the ESA, a temporary layoff is not itself a termination; it only becomes one when the statutory requirements for a temporary layoff are no longer met.
The ONCA found that by referring specifically to a “temporary layoff” in the employment agreement, the parties agreed to be governed by the rules for temporary layoffs, not terminations. Treating a temporary layoff provision as a termination provision would ignore both the legislative intent and the text of the agreement.
The ONCA also rejected the employee’s argument that placing the temporary layoff provision under the “Termination” heading transformed it into a termination provision. Relying on Waksdale, the ONCA held that an employment agreement must be read as a whole and that the location of a provision is not determinative of whether it is a termination provision. Endorsing the application judge’s view that “it is the substance that matters, not the form,” the ONCA also noted that the agreement’s headings were used inconsistently, with a non-compete found in the “Responsibilities” section.
Accordingly, although the temporary layoff provision appeared in the termination section of the employment agreement, it did not become a termination provision and remained enforceable.
The ONCA also emphasized contractual freedom, noting that the ESA recognizes temporary layoffs as a tool for employers managing difficult times. It cautioned against treating a temporary layoff provision as a termination provision where the provision does not serve that function. The ONCA therefore saw no reason to interfere with the parties’ express agreement permitting the employer to temporarily lay off the employee.
What employers should know
Taylor v. Salytics Inc. confirms that an invalid termination provision will not, by itself, render a properly drafted temporary layoff provision unenforceable. The decision reinforces the value of carefully drafted temporary layoff provisions that preserve an employer’s ability to respond flexibly to changing economic or operational circumstances.
In light of Taylor v. Salytics Inc., employers should keep the following in mind:
- Include an express temporary layoff right: employers that may need workforce flexibility should consider including an express ESA-compliant temporary layoff provision in their employment agreements.
- Review employment agreements and relevant past practice before implementing a temporary layoff: before proceeding with a temporary layoff, employers should confirm that they have an express or implied contractual right to impose a temporary layoff, considering the applicable employment agreement and any relevant past practice, and that the proposed layoff will comply with the ESA, including the applicable duration and other statutory requirements.
- Tie temporary layoff provisions expressly to the ESA: the provision in Taylor stated that a temporary layoff “may be implemented in accordance with the requirements of the Employment Standards Act, 2000.” This wording was central to the ONCA’s reasoning. By using the statutory term “temporary layoff” and incorporating the ESA requirements, the parties agreed to be governed by the rules for temporary layoffs, not terminations. In contrast, a provision permitting layoffs beyond the ESA’s temporary layoff limits may result in a constructive dismissal.
- Substance matters more than placement: employers should still aim to organize employment agreements clearly, but Taylor confirms that placing a temporary layoff provision under a “Termination” heading does not, by itself, transform it into a termination provision. Courts will look at the substance and effect of the provision rather than where it appears in the agreement.
If you have any questions about temporary layoffs or this decision, please contact a member of the Labour and Employment Group. Tamara Ticoll is counsel and Shannon Bardin is an associate at Stikeman Elliott in Toronto.