Fantasy football can be fun – but what are the workplace risks?

Legal expert offers tips on how to handle potential issues around performance and conflict

Fantasy football can be fun – but what are the workplace risks?

With the return of NFL football comes a welcome distraction for many people in the workplace —  pools and fantasy football leagues. 

More than 56 million Canadians and Americans participated in fantasy leagues last year, according to the Fantasy Sports & Gaming Association. For many, opponents include coworkers: according to a 2024, Yahoo Fantasy app survey of 1,000 workers, 44 per cent said their main opponents are work colleagues. 

Lorenzo Lisi, partner at Aird & Berlis LLP, says that while colleagues deciding to start their own pools or fantasy football leagues can be "low-risk situations," there are some risks employers can prepare for with proper workplace policies. 

"A casual conversation — 'How did you do in the NFL pool last night?' — is not going to be the issue. It becomes a when it starts to interfere with work. At that point, it is a workplace conduct issue," he says. 

Keep fantasy leagues off company networks 

One of the first things Lisi flags for employers is to look at how employees are getting involved. 

"If employees are hosting or accessing fantasy league platforms using company devices and networks, that could create security risks," he says. 

Those concerns can be addressed through regular workplace policies, especially if employers find employees are spending more company time on these platforms and are, therefore, less productive. 

"General policies about not wasting work time apply here the same way they apply to online shopping or any other non-work activity. It is a productivity issue," he says. 

To address this, Lisi says employers can use software monitoring that falls under the disclosure requirements of Ontario’s Electronic Monitoring Policy under the Employment Standards Act to identify those who might be spending more time on those platforms. "They can identify employees who are spending excessive time on fantasy during work hours and take disciplinary action accordingly," he says. 

When friendly competition turns into conflict 

These games also carry a real risk of affecting overall company culture and interpersonal relations that employers should watch out for, says Lisi.  

That can include feelings of exclusion. Office pools are largely outside-of-work activities, meaning not every employee is going to get an invite. While that is not a prohibited ground of discrimination, he says, it can still affect morale and create a sense of division among colleagues who feel left out. 

 Real disputes and conflict between co-workers can also be an issue employers have to watch for. "There is potential for disputes — over standings, over money owed — and those can spill into the workplace," he says. 

What can start as a friendly office pool can turn into a genuine source of interpersonal tension, Lisi says. Neither of these is a legal problem on its own, but both can negatively impact workplace culture. 

When the boss is in the pool 

When managers and supervisors participate in the same pool as employees, that's where a hierarchy risk comes in, Lisi says. 

Normally, supervisors or managers participating in fantasy pools are not a problem. He says that fantasy picks are individual decisions, and a supervisor in a pool is generally not able to leverage their authority over it.  

The critical rule that should be followed is that no one should use their authority to solicit participation in a pool, he says. 

"No one should be advertising or promoting a betting arrangement through positional power." 

The Yahoo fantasy report found that 47 per cent of employees believe their football fantasy performance should help with performance reviews and raises.

Building a policy that covers the basics 

For most employers, existing policies around technology use and the workplace should be enough to deal with any risks that can occur, Lisi says. 

"The key requirements are: participation must not involve gambling as defined under the Criminal Code; employees must not be participating during work hours; participation must be voluntary; and the activity must never negatively impact workplace culture." 

 

Latest stories