Expert urges HR teams to fix payroll and job records before letter requests arrive
Employment reference letters for immigration applications are exposing a record-keeping gap that Canadian employers often overlook.
When payroll, the HR information system and a manager each describe the same job differently, both the employer’s credibility and the employee’s application can suffer, according to Usman Khalil, partner at MAK Canadian Immigration Services in Mississauga, Ont.
Statistics Canada estimates there were nearly 2.8 million non-permanent residents on July 1, 2026, about 1.5 million of them work permit holders.
Khalil sees the problem from both sides.
“The gap I worry about is when the systems each capture a different piece of the job,” he said to Canadian HR Reporter. “Payroll shows when someone was paid, HR may have a current job title, and the supervisor knows what that person actually did.”
Those differences, he says, can sit unnoticed until an immigration application asks for dates, hours, pay and duties to be confirmed together.
When employment records become evidence
Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) lists an employer reference letter as proof of work experience for Express Entry. Some provincial programs ask for more: Ontario’s Immigrant Nominee Program requests proof of compensation and accepts job descriptions and performance reviews as evidence of duties.
In one case, an employer’s refusal to release financial records led to a residency denial and a misrepresentation finding against the applicant.
Khalil’s answer is prevention. “I would keep a dated record whenever someone’s duties, reporting line, pay, normal hours or work location changes,” he says.
That includes location. “For remote or hybrid arrangements, it helps to know where the work was physically performed, not just that the employee was marked ‘remote’ in the system,” he says.
Reference-letter workflow
When a request arrives, Khalil argues HR should reconcile existing records rather than reconstruct them.
“HR checks the dates and role history, payroll verifies compensation and paid hours, and a manager who knows the work confirms the actual duties,” he says. “An authorized company representative then signs what the organization can support.”
“Where the employer cannot verify a fact, it is better to say so than to create precision that the records don’t support,” he adds.
Records and immigration advice
The same discipline guards against well-meaning staff shaping a letter to help a colleague. “HR can confirm that someone worked in a particular role, during certain dates, for specified pay, doing duties the employer can verify,” Khalil says. “It should not change those facts to fit an immigration category or tell an employee that a letter guarantees permanent residence.”
“Immigration advice provided for consideration is regulated under Canadian law, but a truthful employment record is not automatically immigration advice,” he says.
“An unsupported or embellished letter can create serious problems for the employee; whether a discrepancy amounts to material misrepresentation is a different legal question,” he adds.
Payroll controls issue
Record-keeping is also a compliance obligation in its own right, as an Ontario temp agency fined $125,000 for withholding payroll records discovered. Khalil sees the same issue through an audit lens.
“From a CPA’s perspective, this is a basic controls issue: can the job record, payroll and manager’s account be reconciled?” he says.
His recommendation is to document significant changes “when they happen, with the manager and payroll on the same page.” Accuracy matters as much as completeness: in one case, a Hamilton staffing firm was fined $100,000 for providing false records during an employment standards inspection.
“A good reference letter should come from good records; it shouldn’t be the first time anyone checks them,” Khalil says.